Skip to main content

Scrap metal recyclers explore options to tap into 'greenpremium'

Scrap metal products were being repurposed as part of the green solution to achievedecarbonization, and some major market participants at the beginning of the recycling chainhave been exploring ways to get a slice of the so-called ‘green premium,’ Fastmarkets hasheard.

The use of scrap metal in aluminium and copper production consumes less energy than primarysmelting, and less carbon is emitted during the secondary smelting process as a result.

Many metal producers were now taking pride in using an increasing proportion of secondaryraw materials.

At the Bureau of International Recycling (BIR) conference in Dubai, October 17-18, aluminiumproducer EGA presented to delegates its plan to build the fi rst aluminium recycling plant in theUnited Arab Emirates, while marketing its recycled aluminium under the name EternAL.

Aluminium production consumes the most power among the base metals, and has already seensurcharges built into contracts for specific low-carbon material and scrap-produced foundryalloy.

Last month, copper producer Montanwerke-Brixlegg introduced a premium of €295 ($289) pertonne for its copper cathodes on an fca basis for 2023, targeting a group of “climate-sensitive”clients.

That was notably higher than Aurubis’ 2023 off er of $228 per tonne, and Codelco’s off er in thelow-mid $230s per tonne for the European copper market.

The differential was said to be justifi ed by a lower carbon footprint.

Brixlegg’s cathodes are produced entirely from copper scrap, and the verifi ed product carbonfootprint is 0.739 tonnes of carbon dioxide per tonne of copper cathode produced - the lowest inthe industry. That compared with the industry norm of 4.1 tonnes per tonne of copper,according to the International Copper Alliance.

According to a verifi cation statement that Brixlegg presented earlier this year at Fastmarkets’copper conference in Barcelona, Spain, the carbon footprint was “calculated from acquisition ofcopper scrap until the completion of the copper cathode production process.”

Swedish producer Boliden, meanwhile, separately markets its low-carbon copper products thatproduce less than 1.5kg of carbon dioxide per kg of copper.
Recycler constraints

At the moment, smelters were the major advocates of a green metal premium, while suppliers ofscrap metal were not. This included upstream recyclers such as scrapyards that collect,dismantle, process and shred scrap metal.
“Copper smelters sign long-term contracts to fi x their premiums - they need to do that to planproduction,” a source with a major non-ferrous metal recycler in Europe said. “A green premiumcan be charged on a one-off basis. But recyclers don’t like to have annual contracts. Ourproduction is fast and fl exible all the time, in response to market changes.”

Nonetheless, there were still fresh eff orts among recyclers to better position their scrap metalproducts to clients that care about their carbon footprints.

One of the biggest metals recyclers in Europe was currently in the process of adding carboncertifi cates to its diverse range of products, two sources with direct knowledge of the subjecttold Fastmarkets at a recent industry conference.

Carbon emission benchmarking

But this was not expected to become an industry norm because it was too costly for small andmedium-sized scrapyards to apply for their own carbon certifi cates, the sources said.

The BIR was now in the process of updating benchmark values for carbon emission savings insecondary copper, aluminium and ferrous production, compared with primary smelting, theBIR’s director general, Arnaud Brunet, said on October 16 at a press briefi ng.

The association’s “Report on the Environmental Benefits of Recycling (2016 edition)” said that the benchmark carbon footprint savings between primary copper production (via thepyrometallurgical route) and secondary copper production was 81,000 tonnes of carbon dioxideemissions per 100,000 tonnes of copper.

In aluminium, the benchmark carbon footprint saving between primary and secondaryproduction was 354,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions per 100,000 tonnes of aluminium.And in ferrous metals, the gap between primary and secondary production was 97,000 tonnes ofcarbon dioxide emissions per 100,000 tonnes of steel.